site stats

Sample reviewer comments on a manuscript

WebMay 1, 2024 · An example would be if you’re reviewing a very technical manuscript for a broad journal such as American Psychologist, which focuses on major developments across all of psychology. "In your note to the author, you should feel free to make suggestions about the best place to resubmit the manuscript," Sokol-Chang adds. 5: Map out a plan WebUsing our Rapid Technical Review service, you can get our expert panelists, all of whom have published peer-reviewed papers, to review your paper and provide constructive comments so that you can improve your manuscript BEFORE submission to the journal of your choice. The assessment process applied in the Editage Rapid Technical Review has been ...

As a Peer Reviewer: When you should say Rejected Manuscript?

WebFirst International Congress on Peer Review in Biomedical Publishing.2 However, few studies exist that analyze the content of reviewers’ comments when reviewers are recommending re-jection or acceptance of a manuscript. Gilbert and Chubin1, p. 108 conducted such an analysis for a sample of review-ers’ comments on manuscripts that had WebPeer review, also known as refereeing, is a collaborative process that allows independent experts in the same field of research to evaluate and comment on manuscript submissions. The outcome of a peer review gives authors feedback to improve their work and, critically, allows the editor to assess the paper’s suitability for publication. hiren alternative https://triplebengineering.com

How to review a manuscript - American Psychological Association

WebGeneral Comments from Reviewer 1 Comment: This is an interesting study and the authors have collected a unique dataset using cutting edge methodology. The paper is generally … WebApr 14, 2024 · Abstract: Background: Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a global problem. Resistant bacteria, for many reasons, do not cease to emerge and re-emerge. The impact of AMR on patient therapy is not scares in literature to date, but there is still much to do, mainly in pediatric settings. It is vital to assess the necessity of observing the impact of such … WebIf you received no specific instructions, the reviewer report should be divided into two parts: comments to be read only by the editor, and; comments to be read by both the editor and … hiren and pankaj s homepage

Reviewers

Category:Understanding reviewers comments on research paper

Tags:Sample reviewer comments on a manuscript

Sample reviewer comments on a manuscript

Writing a reviewer report Springer — International Publisher

WebI would recommend the rejection of a manuscript based on the following: 1. The work lacks scientific merit - the manuscript does not make any significant improvement to the … http://perso.citi.insa-lyon.fr/rstanica/reviews/answers1.pdf

Sample reviewer comments on a manuscript

Did you know?

WebAssess the originality (contribution, addition of knowledge to scientific literature or field) of the manuscript. Clearly identify the strengths and weaknesses of the method described in …

WebMay 1, 2024 · This section—usually one to two pages—constitutes the bulk of the review. It summarizes the manuscript’s main points and includes general comments about the … WebFor example: “We wish to thank you and the reviewers for your insightful comments. These have greatly helped us to improve the quality of our manuscript. “ Give an overview/executive brief Provide an overview of the main changes you made to your study and explain how you indicated these revisions in the manuscript.

WebFollowing the invitation to review, when you'll have get the article abstractly, you should existing understand the aims, key data and conclusions of the manuscript. Provided you don't, make a observe now that you need to feedback on how to improve those sections. Reviewers' Comments: Reviewer #1 (Remarks to the Author) This ... WebReviewer B’s Comments to Authors: This manuscript tries to identify clinical and endoscopic features that would help predict cancer progression after EMR of Barrett’s esophagus …

WebSome journals have a space for reviewers to enter confidential comments about the manuscript. Apply dieser space to mention concerns about the submission that you’d want one editors to consider before sharing your give with the authors, suchlike as concerns info ethical guidelines or language quality.

WebMay 8, 2024 · Real time example of Response to Reviewers Comments. Here we have placed the example real-time response to the reviewer’s comments. Each reviewer has … hiren amin religionWeb• Results, powder sample testing no TWC, 2nd paragraph: Need to include comment on carbon balance • Results, powder sample testing no TWC, 2nd paragraph: sentence start … hiren amin prankWebWrapping Up. After you have carefully read the manuscript and taken notes on overall strengths and weaknesses, take another look at the journal’s publication criteria and reviewer guidelines. Determine if you need to look at any part of the manuscript again. Go over your notes and decide what you’ll recommend to the journal. homes for sale on lake mead nv